Tips & Tricks

Best Dog Puzzle Toys for Aussies: From Beginner to Advanced 

beautiful border collie couch

Australian Shepherds are among the smartest dogs on the planet. These clever canines need daily mental stimulation to stay sharp and well-behaved. The best way to provide that? Dog puzzle toys!

As your Aussie grows, it’s essential to do everything you can to enhance their cognitive abilities. Challenging puzzles allow them to develop mentally while also keeping them busy and out of trouble. With so many options available, though, how do you choose the best puzzles for your Aussie pup or adult dog? 

We’ve rounded up the top 6 dog puzzle toys for Australian Shepherds, from beginner level to advanced. These interactive toys will test your dog’s smarts and keep them engaged.

Let’s jump in!

Choosing the Right Puzzle Difficulty Level

Before we get to the specific toy recommendations, let’s talk about how to pick the appropriate puzzle level for your unique Aussie. Getting this right is key to setting your dog up for success.

1. Understand Your Dog’s Play Style

Dogs have different interests when it comes to playtime. Some love toys they can chase and pounce on, while others prefer to carefully sniff out hidden treats.  

Take some time to observe what really gets your Aussie excited. If they have a strong prey drive, a treat-dispensing ball that rolls around erratically could be a great choice – it taps into their natural instincts. For the nosy pups, puzzles with hidden compartments for treats or toys that involve sniffing will probably be more of their jam.

australian shepherd puppy on white wooden cage

2. Assess Their Cognitive Abilities  

Your individual dog’s smarts will depend on factors like their age, past training, and to some extent, their lineage. In general, Aussies are whip-smart, but even within the breed, there’s variation.

Puppies and older dogs may need to start with simpler puzzles, while Aussies in their prime can often handle more complex challenges. The best way to determine your dog’s skill level is to start with a basic puzzle and see how easily they solve it. If they figure it out right away, try a slightly harder toy.

Note that puzzle-solving abilities are something you can improve with practice. The more your Aussie uses their brain, the better they’ll get at conquering even the trickiest toys. So don’t be afraid to introduce progressively harder options as your dog builds mental muscle.

a person petting a brown and white long coated dog

3. Provide Puzzle Training If Needed

Some high-level puzzles may be a bit much for your Aussie to figure out on their own. That’s totally normal! There’s nothing wrong with giving your pup a little puzzle training to set them up for success.

If a new toy is leaving your Aussie stumped, demonstrate how it works. For puzzles with compartments, start by leaving them open so your dog can see the treats inside. If there are moving parts, guide them with your hand to show how they function.

Praise and encourage your dog whenever they make progress, even if they don’t fully solve the puzzle. Keep it positive, and be patient. The goal is to build their confidence and drive to keep trying, not to make them feel discouraged.

It’s also wise to have a range of puzzle difficulties on hand. You never want to go from super easy to ultra hard in one leap. Let your dog work their way up as their skills improve.


Now, let’s get to those toy recommendations!

Best 6 Puzzle Toys for Australian Shepherds

We’ve categorized our top picks by difficulty level, from entry-level to expert. Here are the best interactive puzzle toys to challenge your Aussie’s mind:

Beginner Puzzle: House-Shape Interactive Dog Toy

For Aussies who are new to the world of food puzzles, the simple but engaging House-Shape Interactive Dog Game is a perfect starting point. 

The curved compartments are deep enough to hold fragrant rewards like soft Bacon Bites. The scent will motivate your Aussie to paw and mouth at the pieces to get them out. This is doggy problem-solving 101.


We love this pick for puppies because it’s 100% made from chew-resistant bamboo. Those needle-sharp puppy teeth are no match for this durable toy! You can feel confident leaving your young Aussie to work on this puzzle solo. 

Beginner Puzzle: Rolling Drum Treat Dispenser

Another fun entry-level option is the Loobani Rolling Drum. The concept is simple: you place treats or kibble inside the plastic drum, which has small holes around the outside. As your Aussie bats and rolls the toy around, reward bits fall out.


This is more of a physical puzzle than a mental one, but it still encourages your dog to use trial and error to get their treats. And, of course, it’s fantastic for high-energy Aussies who need to burn off steam with active play.


You can adjust the opening size to make the puzzle easier or harder—larger holes release treats more quickly. There’s also an optional durable bamboo stand that holds the rolling drum, adding an extra element of challenge as your dog figures out how to turn and angle it to dispense its goodies.

Great for dogs who are easily bored or need a lot of physical exercise in addition to mental stimulation. 

Intermediate Puzzle: Loobani Turn Around Interactive Dog Toy  

This unique puzzle will put your Aussie’s creativity to the test! It features three tubes your dog must flip upside down and balance to get the treats out. That’s harder than it sounds, the food must be just right to spill out through the opening in the bottle cap. If too much food gets stuck in the opening, the snacks won’t come out.


The key skill here is patience. Your eager Aussie must learn to carefully tip a tube, then quickly use their nose or paw to stabilize it long enough for the treats to fall out. They’ll likely spill quite a few snacks in the process, but that’s part of the fun.


It’s perfect for smart dogs who need to practice slowing down and thinking through their problem-solving approach.

Advanced Puzzle: Multi-Level Turn Around Interactive Dog Toy

For brainy Aussies who conquer the three-tube balancing toy with ease, it’s time to level up to the multi-compartment version. This puzzle features different kinds of treat-hiding spots – ones your dog must push, slide, and spin.

The variety is great for keeping clever dogs on their toes. Now, they can’t just repeat the same flipping motion over and over. They must use their paws and noses in different ways to release the rewards.


It’s a great pick for quick learners and adult dogs who are getting bored with repetitive puzzles. This will reignite their enthusiasm for the game.

Advanced Puzzle: Hide-n-Slide Puzzle Without Plastic

This spiffy toy looks great and offers a serious mental workout for your Aussie. It includes a frame with 8 hidden compartments concealed by 4 shutter-style sliding bamboo panels for interactive play.

Your pup must use their nose and paws to push and pull the panels in different directions to uncover their prizes. It’s a test of spatial awareness and logical thinking. They have to focus on how the parts relate to the whole.

Because there are so many compartments and possible panel positions, this puzzle has great replay value. You can hide treats in different spots every time.  


Once your Aussie has the basic idea down, kick it up a notch by placing pieces of fabric or paper over the treat spots before sliding the panels over. This adds a scent work element as your dog learns to sniff out the hidden rewards.

Expert Puzzle: Triple Layer Dog Puzzle Board

Is your Australian Shepherd a certified puzzle prodigy? The Triple Layer Dog Puzzle Board will finally give their intellect a run for its money. This is the “final boss” of dog puzzles! 

Picture this: three rotating layers stacked like a doggy-sized cake. The bottom layer is lined with tempting treat compartments. The second layer also hides a few treat spots of its own. And the top layer? That’s a spinning disc that determines your pup’s snacking fate.

Here’s where the brainpower comes in. To reach the treats on the second level, your Aussie just needs to rotate the top disc. Pretty simple, right? But if they want to hit the jackpot and uncover the bottom-level goodies, they’ll need to get strategic.


Only by rotating both the top disc and the second layer in perfect synchronicity can your clever canine reveal all the hidden compartments. It’s like a dog-friendly Rubik’s Cube!

Prepare to watch your Aussie puzzle over this one for a while. They’ll need to test out different disc positions, paw carefully at the second layer to line things up just right, and probably perform a few spins themselves for good measure. It’s a mental exercise to the max.

The Triple Layer Dog Puzzle Board is doggy brain fuel, plain and simple. It pushes your Aussie to think hard, get creative, and refuse to give up until they emerge victorious. For a dog who thrives on tackling the toughest challenges around, this puzzle is pure gold.

More to Mentally Stimulate Your Aussie

In addition to using interactive puzzle toys, there are other great ways to keep your Aussie mentally sharp:

1. Let Them Explore

One of the easiest ways to stimulate your Aussie’s mind is to simply let them be a dog! Give them the freedom to sniff, dig, and investigate to their heart’s content (in a safe area).

Following scent trails, discovering new textures, and tracking down the sources of interesting sounds are all amazingly enriching for your pup. It lets them use their natural canine senses and satisfy their curiosity about the world.

walk the dog

2. Make Meals More Challenging  

Instead of feeding your Aussie from a bowl, let them work for their food! Scatter their kibble in the snuffle mat or stuff it into a Kong or other puzzle feeder.

This mimics the natural style of foraging that dogs evolved to do. It makes mealtime way more exciting and can help combat gulping, bloating, and boredom.

If you like, you can feed all your Aussie’s meals this way. Just be sure to choose a method that slows them down without being so hard that they get frustrated.

dog snuffle mat

3. Teach New Tricks  

Learning new behaviors is one of the absolute best ways to keep your Aussie’s mind active. And with a dog this smart, the sky really is the limit in terms of what you could teach.

Take some time every day to work on basic obedience skills or flashier tricks. Staples like sit, down, stay, and come lay an important foundation that you can build on with more complex tasks later.

Once your Aussie has the basics down pat, try teaching them tricks like spinning in a circle, weaving through your legs, or even bringing you a drink from the fridge. Aussies are amazing at chaining behaviors together!  

Not only does tick training stimulate your dog’s mind, but it enhances your bond and helps them stay focused even in the face of distractions. It’s really a win all around.

the girl and the dog are playing

Final Words

From beginner level to super advanced, dog puzzle toys offer an amazing way to challenge your Aussie’s intellect, tickle their senses, and encourage their natural problem-solving skills. They’re so much more than just playthings!

When choosing the best interactive toys for your dog, consider their chewing habits, food motivation, and current skill level. Don’t be afraid to think outside of the box and get creative. The more variety you offer, the more enriching the experience will be.

If you hit a wall with a new toy, take a step back and do some puzzle training. Your Aussie will be tackling the toughest toys on the market before you know it. 

Mental exercise is just as important as keeping them physically active for these smart herding dogs. With the right food puzzles in your toy box, your Aussie will never want terrific cognitive workouts. Let the games begin!


About Zelda D.Nelson

As a lifelong dog lover and proud mom to two energetic rescue pups, I know firsthand how important puzzle toys are for providing dogs with much-needed mental and physical stimulation. After over a decade of experience raising well-adjusted, happy dogs, I joined the Loobani Pet team to help other pet parents discover the joy and benefits of dog puzzles. Through my work at Loobani Pet, I've become an expert on the ins and outs of various interactive dog toys. My goal is to simplify the selection process so you can easily pinpoint the perfect puzzles to match your pup's needs and lifestyle. Whether you need a toy to challenge your brainy breed, keep your power chewer occupied, or simply provide some rainy day fun, I've got you covered.